Facts About Wal-Mart And Local Economies
Background on
Wal-Mart’s Exploding Growth Affecting America’s Towns
·
Last Year
Wal-Mart Opened 312 Stores in the United States. In its Fiscal Year 2005
alone, Wal-Mart added 36 discount stores, 242 Super Centers, 21 Neighborhood
Markets, and 13 Sam’s Clubs to their empire in the United States. [SEC,
form 10-K for FY2005]
· Wal-Mart CFO Shoewe: 950 New Supercenters Have Already Been Planned Internally. “[T]he bottom line is there is a tremendous opportunity, something just under 4000 Supercenters that can be added to what we already have here, and 950 of those have already gone through the internal process -- internal real estate process that is just awesome.” [Wal-Mart CFO Tom Schoewe, Remarks at the Wal-Mart Shareholders' Meeting Presentation to Analysts, 6/3/05]
Wal-Mart Eliminates
Business from Local Shops when it Enters a Community
·
Wal-Mart
Effect on Grocery Markets: Most People In The U.S. Spend More Money In
Grocery Stores Than In Any Other Type Of Store. One Iowa State University study of Supercenter impact on local
economies showed a food store market sales decrease of 10%
in the counties studied one year after opening, and a decrease of 19.2% by the
fifth year of operation. [Stone,
Kenneth E.; Artz, Georgeanne; Myles, Albert, The Economic Impact of Wal-Mart Supecenters on Existing Businesses in
Mississippi]
·
Wal-Mart
Effect on Specialty Stores: Drug
stores, sporting goods stores, book stores, gift shops, are examples of
specialty stores. A study of Iowa
communities showed an 8% decrease in specialty store sales the first year a Wal-Mart
store opened in town. The study showed a decrease of 13.9% after 5 years. [Stone, Kenneth E., Competing with the Discount Mass Merchandisers, Iowa State
University]
·
Wal-Mart Effect
on Apparel Sales: The study of Iowa communities showed even more
dramatic data for clothing sales. The first year after a Wal-Mart store
opened in a town, other apparel retailers lost 7.9% of their sales. After five
years, the figure was 17.9%. [Stone, Kenneth E.,
Competing with the Discount Mass
Merchandisers, Iowa State University]
Wal-Mart Builds
Stores with Public Subsidies, Takes Away Funds for Local Spending
Wal-Mart has Received Over $1 billion in Public
Subsidies. Despite $10 billion in
profit in 2004 alone, Wal-Mart relies on state and local governments to provide
tax breaks and to pay for roads and utility connections at many of its new
stores and distribution centers. A May 2004 report by Good Jobs First
documented that Wal-Mart has received more than $1 billion from at least 244 taxpayer-funded subsidies. [Mattera and Purinton, Good Jobs First, “Shopping
for Subsidies,” May 2004, http://www.goodjobsfirst.org/pdf/wmtstudy.pdf]
Examples of Wal-Mart Subsidies. The public money Wal-Mart receives comes in the following forms: Free or reduced price land, Tax Increment Finance (TIF) districts, Infrastructure assistance, Property tax breaks, State corporate income tax credits, Sales tax rebates, Tax-exempt bond financing, Enterprise Zone status, Job training/recruiting funds, General grants. [CITE]
Other Uses for Public
Funds Given to Wal-Mart:
·
Property taxes
are usually used by municipal governments for things like schools, road repair,
garbage pickup, and other such services [Legal
Information Institute, Cornell University].
·
Bond money:
companies seek and receive bond money because the interest rate is very
favorable, as the loan is guaranteed by a government agency. This is taxpayer money
they’re borrowing.